Are Investors Trapped?

InvestorsDuring the season, the waters in the Florida Keys are decorated with various colored buoys attached to lobster traps. The symbols are akin to branding cattle.

Don’t even think about rustling lobster from someone else’s trap! You could end up in the middle of the ocean with a sinking boat full of bullet holes.

Lobster fishing is different. Maine Lobster Now tells us:

“Lobsters walk along the ocean floor…. Lobster traps are made for the lobsters to walk right into the trap, it’s easy for them to walk in, but once they are in … they cannot walk out.

…. The lobsterman places a piece of fresh or salted fish in the trap. …. (Traps) are taken out on the lobster boat and lowered to the ocean floor on a rope with a floating marker buoy at the other end. ….

The lobster trap is a method that works and has stood the test of time (200 years!).”

Have investors been lured into a trap?

In 2013, John Mauldin and Jonathan Tepper authored, “Code Red, How to protect your Savings from the Coming Crisis”. It outlines how central banks lowered interest rates to historically low levels (Zero Interest Rate Policy – ZIRP); herding yield starved savers into the stock market:

“In a ZIRP world, debtors are overjoyed, and savers are screwed.

…. Imagine you’re a retiree, and you’ve been responsible and saved all your life; you’ve put money in the bank that you expect to pay you interest every month. You probably bought some bonds as well, so you could collect coupons every quarter. In a ZIRP world, you would be getting very little every month from interest…. You would live your retirement years with far less income than you had planned for, or you would need to work far longer in order to save more.

…. (Fed Chairman) Bernanke openly acknowledges that his low interest-rate policy is designed to get savers and investors to take more chances with riskier investments. The fact that this is precisely the wrong thing for retirees and savers seems to be lost in their pursuit of market and economic gains.” (Emphasis mine)

Their comments about a 2012 speech by Fed Chairman Ben Bernanke are taking shape:

“LSAPs (Large Scale Asset Purchases) also appear to have boosted stock prices, … it is probably not a coincidence that the sustained recovery in U.S. equity prices began in March 2009, shortly after the FOMC’s decision to greatly expand securities purchases. This effect is potentially important because stock values affect both consumption and investment decisions.

These remarks are vintage Bernanke. If you’re an investor or speculator, the message is loud and clear: Buy stocks. We’ve got your back. (But let’s see who takes the blame when the stock market falls next time. Just saying…)”

Help keep us on the air!

We’re committed to keeping our weekly letters FREE.

It’s humbling when readers suggested we add a donations button to help us offset the costs.

It’s strictly voluntary – no pressure – no hassle! Click the DONATE button below for more information.

And thank you all!

PS: You do not have to sign up for PayPal to use your credit card.

The herding is massive

Investors flocked to their brokers and financial managers for help. The financial industry trumpeted the message that individual investors could not beat the market; invest in managed funds. Fill out the forms and they’ll feed your information into the computer. Let the computer do all the work, it’s simple, safe and easy!

Trillions of dollars were herded into company managed funds, diversified for safety; protecting the individual investor from catastrophic losses.

What happens when the stock market falls?

A Financial Sense article by Jim Puplava, “Liquidity Crisis Looming” paints a different picture:

“On a daily basis, almost 90 percent of trading on exchanges is carried out through high-frequency trading and index investing….

We’re seeing a greater concentration of risk among passive index funds and ETFs. The top 10 holders of the FANG (Facebook, Amazon, Netflix, and Google) stocks are all index funds….

Today, index funds account for 43 percent of all stock fund assets, and this is projected to be 50 percent in the next 3 years….

In total, index funds represent $7 trillion of U.S. stock funds that have no active manager. All buying and selling are done automatically.

Ownership of stocks in the S&P 500 is concentrated with three companies: Vanguard, BlackRock, and State Street. They represent about 88 percent of the S&P 500, and if we include Schwab and Fidelity, over 90 percent of the S&P 500 is basically now in the hands of five companies. (Emphasis mine)”

Friend John Mauldin’s article “Bubbles, Bubbles Everywhere” explains the anatomy of bubbles and crashes. How do investors avoid the trap?

“We know of one hedge fund in 1999 that had made fortunes for its clients investing in legitimate tech stocks. They decided it was a bubble and elected to close down the fund and return the money in the latter part of 1999. It took a year of concerted effort to close all their positions out. While their investors had fabulous returns, this just illustrates that exiting a bubble can be hard even for professionals. And in illiquid markets? Forget about it! (Emphasis mine)

Market crashes are inevitable. The Federal Reserve and central banks pumped up the current market bubble to historic proportions through their ZIRP. Trillions of dollars have been herded into index funds with a concentration of wealth never seen before.

The Fed is now reversing the course and raising interest rates; which will eventually cause the market to drop.

What happens when investors get frightened and want to get out of the market?

We agree with Jim Puplave’s concern:

“This may leave us facing nasty results, because in the event of a market downturn, as these ETFs and passive index funds crowd to exit their positions, they create a market liquidity trap as there is no one left to sell to.” (Emphasis mine)

What happens if the big five, controlling 90% of the S&P 500, put in huge sell orders. Will there be a market? Who will take the other side of the trade?

Much like water circling a drain, as the market drop accelerates, sell orders trigger more sell orders by the automated traders, causing the market to drop faster and dramatically….

Where will it end? How low will it go? Which accounts will be looked after versus those who take the biggest loss?

I contacted John Mauldin, reminding him of his comments, “And in illiquid markets? Forget about it!” Here is what he said:

“Most everyone knows the market is on thin ice and thinks they are smart enough to get out the door ahead of the other guy when the market turns. With computer trading and all the tools available to the big boys, the individual investor will be at the back of the line. The technical term is screwed!

You are right to be fearful. We just don’t know when.”

Millions of investors took the bait and poured money into funds. If the market turns and becomes illiquid, are they trapped? In a crash people panic. Can they possibly exit without taking catastrophic losses?

What is a share of stock really worth?

You can do all the technical analysis you want; however, the market is not orderly. It’s only worth what someone is willing to pay at the moment you want to sell.

Will investors be faced with two choices – holding on while their nest egg drops by double digits, hoping it will come back in their lifetime – or selling during the panic and taking catastrophic losses?

What will their brokers and financial advisors be telling them to do? Many will say hang on – a market crash presents great buying opportunities. Yeah right! Only for those who accumulated cash and patiently waited for the crash.

Does the market always come back? In our article, “Will Someone Please Tell The Truth” we looked at the facts. After the 2000 crash, the NASDAQ (adjusted for inflation) has yet to recover the buying power from the previous high.

In March 2000 the S&P 500 index reached an all-time high of $1,552.87. Nine years later it closed at $676.53. When adjusted for inflation, it took 17 years (Dec 2016), and a wild ride, to recover the previous buying power.

Can you afford to wait for 10-20 years hoping your life savings will recover the buying power it lost during a catastrophic down turn?


Our friend Tim Plaehn at The Dividend Hunter has set up a unique Monthly Dividend Paycheck Calendar system that can provide you with an average of $4,000 a month in extra income based on a model portfolio of $500,000.

For a limited time, he’s offering readers a 50% discount on the first year of a subscription: just $49.

CLICK HERE for more information.

What should investors do?

No one knows when the inevitable market crash will come or how bad it will be. Each person must assess their own situation, time frame, and investment goals.

Here are some things to consider.

  • Do a complete financial analysis. How much of your net worth is in the stock market? How much is in bonds, mutual funds or ETFs? Are you comfortable with the allocations in today’s environment?
  • Have a serious discussion with your financial professional. Ask about the small print in the fund prospectus. You may be surprised that they do not have to liquidate your investment as quickly as you think.
  • Reassess your priorities. Is return of your money more important today than the return on your money?
  • Trust your judgment. While your long-term broker may be a friend, they are pressured to keep all their clients invested in their company fee-based funds. Moving some money from stock funds into short-term, safe interest-bearing CDs may be prudent.
  • Learn the difference between a mutual fund versus an ETF. You can trade an ETF online during trading hours. Mutual fund buy/sell orders are placed, and you don’t know your yield until the end of the trading day.

Today investors can unwind their positions and avoid the trap. As John Mauldin cautioned, “You are right to be fearful. We just don’t know when.” Once the programmed traders sell alarms goes off, it will get ugly!


Chuck Butler writes a weekly column for The Dow Theory Letters. I’m impressed with the quality of the research. They provide a terrific guide for portfolio allocation – including precious metals.

They have offered Miller On The Money readers – a special introductory discount – 10% off their 3-month trial, or 15% off a full year subscription.

CLICK HERE to order the 3-month trial.

CLICK HERE to order the full year subscription.

These are special links for OUR READERS ONLY and the discounts are factored in.

On The Lighter Side

I want to say a big “THANK YOU” to friend Chuck Butler who writes “The Daily Pfennig”. He recently told his readers about our FREE report, “10 Easy Steps To The Ultimate Worry-Free Retirement Plan”. I was overwhelmed. Welcome to our new readers. I will work hard to live up to the kind words Chuck had to say.

Chuck and I are just two seniors who enjoy writing and hopefully helping others figure out how to build and maintain their nest egg. “The Daily Pfennig” is also FREE – a must read.

And finally…

Thanks to those who took the time to write comments about last week’s interview with Aja McClanahan. She has the gift of being able to educate and motivate people to take charge of their lives.

The day the article was released, I took the family out for our favorite Indiana pizza (Turoni’s). Above the door was a cool sign that summed things up well:

Turonis Pizza

We are in charge of our happiness.

“Life is not always a matter of holding good cards,
but sometimes, playing a poor hand well.”

…. Jack London

Until next time…

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *