Big Brother’s Bank Bailouts Bankrupting Baby Boomers
In 2008, almost overnight, Americans were told the economic system was on the verge of collapse and needed a one-time bailout. Congress quickly passed the Troubled Assets Relief Program (TARP). Interest rates dropped to historic lows.
This was to jump-start the economy and interest rates would quickly return to normal. Eight years, and several bailouts later, we still have historically low rates, high debt, a terrible economy while baby boomers scramble to make ends meet.
I’m still haunted by the movie, “The Big Short”. The following graphic appeared on the screen and a conversation took place in the background.
“When the dust settled from the collapse, $5 trillion dollars in pension money, real estate values, 401 (k), savings and bonds disappeared.”
It was a conversation between two high-level investment advisors. “There’s gonna be a bailout!” one exclaimed. The other responds, “The banks knew it all along”. The banks knew they could take unfathomable risks because the government would bail them out at the expense of taxpayers.
It should not be a surprise
I recall the story of a turtle and snail having a head on collision. A TV reporter stuck a microphone in the snail’s face and asked, “How did it happen?” The snail replied, “I don’t know, it happened so fast!”
In his book, “Don’t Bank on It”, Craig Smith tells us we were warned.
In 1834 President Jackson was adamant in his thoughts about the bankers:
“I too have been a close observer of the Bank of the United States…. I have had men watching you…. and am convinced that you have used the funds of the bank to speculate in the breadstuffs of the country.
“When you won, you divided the profits amongst you, and when you lost, you charged it to the bank.”…. You are a den of vipers and thieves…”
Minnesota Congressman Charles A. Lindbergh, (father of the later-to-be-famous aviator) issued this warning:
“The financial system…. has been turned over to the Federal Reserve Board,” wrote Lindbergh. “That board administers the finance system by authority of…. a purely profiteering group.”
Nothing has changed; banks keep the profits and stick taxpayers with the losses. Maybe the snail was surprised but the rest of us had plenty of warnings.
Goosing the accelerator
We are hearing political debate about the Glass-Steagall act, a law passed in 1933 and repealed during the Clinton administration in 1999.
Joseph Stiglitz, Nobel Prize winner in economics tells us:
“Glass-Steagall had long separated commercial banks (which lend money) and investment banks (which organize the sale of bonds and equities)….
Commercial banks are not supposed to be high-risk ventures; they are supposed to manage other people’s money very conservatively. It is with this understanding that the government agrees to pick up the tab should they fail.
Investment banks, on the other hand, have traditionally managed rich people’s money-people who can take bigger risks in order to get bigger returns.
When repeal of Glass-Steagall brought investment and commercial banks together, the investment-bank culture came out on top. There was a demand for the kind of high returns that could be obtained only through high leverage and big risk taking.”
The repeal of the act goosed the accelerator and created a small number of huge investment banks. CNBC tells us “Five biggest banks now own almost half the industry.” I’m sure the political class would continue to label them, “Too Big To Fail”. For both sides of the political debate, click here and here.
The Retirement Problem
Big Brother’s bank bailouts are bankrupting baby boomers and retirees. It’s now impossible for an individual or pension fund manager to generate enough risk-free income to provide for a comfortable retirement.
Why? Because the Federal Reserve and political class decided protecting the banks was more important than protecting seniors and savers.
Bailout de jour
The Wall Street Journal tells us “Public Pensions Roll Back Return Targets” with the average target now averaging 7.68% return.
The least risky non-investment grade (junk) bonds average effective yield is around 5.85%. How much risk do pension fund managers need to take to hit their 7.68% target? You don’t have to be a snail to see that some will make bad decisions and a lot of innocent taxpayers and retirees will suffer.
1. As a result of actuaries revising estimates Bloomberg reports “Chicago’s pension problem just got $11.5 billion bigger”. I was delighted to read:
“…. New accounting rules, (were) adopted to keep governments from using overly optimistic investment-return forecasts to mask the scale of their liabilities…. As a result, the reported liabilities jump.”
They should call this the “Snail Protection Rule” so they can clearly see what’s coming.
2. The underfunded union managed Central States Pension Fund covering retired and active truckers, wanted to institute pension cuts. The government rejected the plan. Politicians wouldn’t want to bail out 250,000 union members with our tax dollars now would they?
3. Recently the House of Representatives passed a Fiscal Rescue Bill to “rescue” Puerto Rico. While the senate has yet to act, the bill is described as “…. An orderly restructuring of the island’s debts in a process akin to bankruptcy.”
House Speaker Paul Ryan said, “This bill prevents a bailout; that’s the entire point… If we do not pass this bill, then there is much more likely going to be a bailout, because there is no other choice.”
Mr. Speaker –
o What’s the difference between a rescue and a bailout?
o Why does the choice always have to be rewarding those who made bad decisions at the expense of the hard-working US taxpayers?
Why don’t they stop the insanity?
The Zero Interest Rate Policy is not working and will not work. Why continue destroying the retirement dreams of many generations?
The economic debate is between “Capitalists” and “Keynesian” economists. Capitalists believe in the free market system that has resulted in the highest standard of living the world has ever seen. It is not flawless as evidenced by the trust busting days in the early 1900’s.
UK economist John Maynard Keynes developed the Keynesian Economic theory. It was born out of the Great Depression of the 1930’s. BusinessDictionary.com explains the difference this way:
“The main plank of his revolutionary theory (emphasis mine) is the assertion that the aggregate demand created by households, businesses and the government and not the dynamics of free markets is the most important driving force in an economy.
….Keynesian economists urge and justify a government’s intervention (emphasis mine) in the economy…. to achieve full employment and price stability. Their ideas have greatly influenced governments the world-over in accepting their responsibility to provide full or near-full employment through measures (such as deficit spending) that stimulate aggregate demand.”
Theoretically government and central banks market intervention can make things all better.
The European Union, Japan, China and the US have primed the pump with a fire hose and it’s not working. Could the theory be wrong? It’s never been proven to work.
The dirty political secret
When the government and central banks intervene, they now have the power to determine winners and losers; it is no longer left to the free market. The bailout list is now 16 pages long and includes more than banks.
The symbiotic relationship between the Federal Reserve and political class is a mutual protection scheme. The Fed’s low interest rate policy allows the politicians to spend freely to buy votes. Individual banks spend millions for political donations and speaking fees for selected, influential politicians. In turn the political class protects the banks.
Famed economist John Kenneth Galbraith gets to the heart of the matter:
“People of privilege will always risk their complete destruction rather than surrender any material part of their advantage. Intellectual myopia, often called stupidity, is no doubt a reason. But the privileged also feel that their privileges, however egregious they may seem to others, are a solemn, basic, God-given right. The sensitivity of the poor to injustice is a trivial thing compared with that of the rich.
All successful revolutions are the kicking in of a rotten door.”
Politicians will continue to bail out banks and “privileged” blocks of voters to insure they stay in power. The injustice imposed on our society by the government and Federal Reserve is horrendous.
Only political establishment snails should be surprised at the support for “non-establishment” candidates in our upcoming election. The public is kicking the rotten door and the political establishment is fighting hard to maintain their power.
What can we do?
I fear Mr. Galbraith may be right when he says, “People of privilege will always risk their complete destruction rather than surrender any material part of their advantage.” In the meantime:
1. Demand our elected officials break up the banks deemed “Too Big to Fail”.
2. Demand they stop using our money to reward bad decisions and penalize those who played by the rules and made responsible decisions. Our system allows us to fire these “people of privilege”. Voters can punish those who spend our money wastefully and reward those who don’t. The political class should be worried.
3. Accept the cold hard facts – we are responsible for our own financial health. Earn more than you spend, and save the difference. The government is not going to bail us out.
We can’t change the past; however, like the turtle and the snail we can get our collective heads out of our shell and prevent another calamity! It’s time for Big Brother to break up the big banks and serve the voters.
On the Lighter Side
I try to end each week with something light. This week I must make an exception and say our hearts and prayers goes out to the families of those who were injured or killed by the recent terrorist attack in Orlando. An event of this magnitude used to unite our country against a common enemy.
Instead the political class jumps on this tragic event for political purposes. While it’s a debate I prefer not to enter; we should remember the primary purpose of the federal government is “to provide for the common defense”; protecting our citizens from harm. The public is getting fed up with “political correctness”.
Good friend Courtenay W. sends along some quotes attributed to ancient Greek philosophers:
- Good people do not need laws to tell them to act responsibly, while bad people will find a way around the laws. – Plato
- Our object in the construction of the state is the greatest happiness of the whole, and not that of any one class. – Plato
And the timeless favorite:
- We hang the petty thieves and appoint the great ones to public office. – Aesop
Until next time…